Simply put, survivorship bias is your tendency to focus on survivors instead of whatever you would call a nonsurvivor depending on the situation. Good practice in research involves considering diverse sources of biases when designing a study for later validation of results. They dont make music like they used to like in those days. By contrast, casecontrol studies cannot provide incidence rates. Apr 20, 2019 survivorship bias is often a form of selection bias, and sometimes further of cherry picking. When our guitar breaks, we may think they dont make em like they used to. Case losses in pancreatic cancer casecontrol studies could therefore introduce survivor bias, especially for those risk factors of pancreatic cancer incidence that are also conditionally associated with survival time. Such system include cancer registries and death certification. Sometimes that means you tend to focus on the living instead of the dead, or on winners instead of losers, or on successes instead of failures. However, selection of cases can result in bias as well, which is less well recognized. Survival bias, a form of ascertainment bias due to selective exclusion of individuals who suffer mortality related to the disease being studied, is difficult to predict, estimate, or control 35.
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the impact of survivor bias on pancreatic cancer case control studies. Strengths of casecontrol studies fewer ethical concerns than experimental studies. Role of survivor bias in pancreatic cancer casecontrol. Selection bias in casecontrol studies elizabeth lynch. There is in particular one type of bias, survivor bias sb, or immortal time bias, that is universally cited as the flaw that puts the validity of p. Study design and settinga casecontrol study was used to analyze the effect of statins on major bleedings during treatment with vitamin k. People who develop serious infections or other problems early on drop out of. It is always important to mentally note the presence of survivorship bias so that one can account for it at the end of the day. However, selection bias due to improper case sampling is less well recognized. Limitations and biases in cohort studies intechopen. In a casecontrol study selection bias occurs when subjects for the control group are not truly representative of the population that produced the. Mostly, the unusual property in question is a track record of success like the successful funds. Uncovering selection bias in casecontrol studies using bayesian poststrati. Introduction to study designs casecontrol studies health.
If selection bias is suspected, there are circumstances under which it is possible to attempt to adjust for it. Stratify on survival time and use a negative control. Those exposed have a greater sensitivity for recalling exposure reduced specificity specifically important in casecontrol studies when exposure history is obtained retrospectively cases may more closely scrutinize their past history looking for ways to explain their illness. Survivor bias occurs when exposed cases are less likely to take part in a study e. Based on these models, we simulated casecontrol genetic association studies for genetic risk factors of varying effect sizes, lethality, and minor allele frequencies. To identify one aspect of the study management process that can improve data quality. Genetic association tests using a casecontrol design depend on comprehensive ascertainment of cases to ensure an accurate representation of causal factors for analysis. Assistant professor institute of clinical pharmacy and pharmaceutical sciences, national cheng kung university 30 th annual meeting of the international society for pharmacoepidemiology taipei, taiwan october 23, 2014 1. Case control studies e r i c n o t e b o o k s e r i e s case control studies are used to determine if there is an association between an exposure and a specific health outcome. May 23, 20 simply put, survivorship bias is your tendency to focus on survivors instead of whatever you would call a nonsurvivor depending on the situation.
Received for publication may 8, 1991, and in final form february 11. Survivor treatment selection bias in observational studies. Selection bias controls are used to provide an estimate of the exposure rate in the population. Survival bias in observational studies of the impact of routine immunizations on childhood survival henrik jensen 1, christine stabell benn, ida maria lisse1,2, amabelia rodrigues, per kragh andersen3 and peter aaby1 1 bandim health project, danish epidemiology science centre and statens serum institut, copenhagen, denmark. Survival bias in observational studies of the impact of. Richardsonb casecontrol studies are particularly prone to selection bias, which can affect odds ratio estimation. To learn how selection bias can occur and some strategies to minimize it 3. In case control studies, survivor bias can occur when cases are selected a long period following the event being studied, with exposed cases having an increased risk of severe illness or death compared with nonexposed cases during the selection period. The authors constructed five caseloss scenarios based on the iowa womens health study cohort to reflect how case recruitment in population. Strengths of case control studies fewer ethical concerns than experimental studies. Berkesonian bias is a bias introduced in hospital based case control studies, due to varying rates of hospital admissions. For each disease, erosion of detected effect size was larger for casecontrol studies of individuals of advanced age age 75 years andor variants with very high event. Casecontrol studies are commonly used because it is an efficient way to study rare outcomes. Request pdf role of survivor bias in pancreatic cancer casecontrol studies purpose.
Approaches to mitigating this bias involve complex statistical models. Selection bias in case control studies is well known to occur when control selection is inappropriate. Selection bias in casecontrol studies is well known to occur when. Future casecontrol studies should pay particular attention to the entire process of subject case and control selection, inclusion, and participation. Selection biases may originate at the time of enrolling the subjects of study, making it necessary to clearly state the selection criteria of the exposed and nonexposed individuals. A casecontrol study also known as casereferent study is a type of observational study in which two existing groups differing in outcome are identified and compared on the basis of some supposed causal attribute. Prevalence of survivor bias in observational studies on. Many cohort studies make use of existing routine, surveillance systems to ascertain the outcomes of interest. Jan 21, 2018 survivorship bias also presents a problem in the medical aspect like in clinical studies. Survivorship bias, war, and abraham walds observation in one of the most famous studies designed to counter survivorship bias, abraham wald set out to determine the weaknesses of airplanes in world war ii for the center of naval analyses.
Apr 01, 2011 survival bias represents a substantial concern in the design of case control genetic association studies of disease with high fatality rates. Genetic association tests employing a casecontrol design depend on comprehensive ascertainment of cases in order to ensure an accurate representation of causal factors for analysis 1,2. E studies in doubt sb is actually not uncommon in observational studies. It is a concern no matter what the design of the study or what statistic is.
My first example is about case control studies of pancreatic cancer, which is when people with pancreatic cancer are compared to similar people without it in order to determine risk factors. Refusal, nonresponse, or agreement to participate that is related to the exposure and disease selfselection bias using the general population as a comparison group for an occupational cohort study healthy worker effect differential referral or diagnosis of subjects. The case control case referent design is really an efficient sampling technique for measuring exposuredisease associations in a cohort that is being followed up or study base all casecontrol studies are done within some cohort defined or not in reality, the distinction between cohort and casecontrol designs is artificial. Research methods in epidemiology, v bias in casecontrol studies. In walds problem, the military focused on the planes. A third source of bias, confounding, is not considered in this article. When case control studies were first developed, most were conducted retrospectively, and it is sometimes assumed that the raredisease assumption applies to all case control studies. Role of survivor bias in pancreatic cancer casecontrol studies. Consideration of the time of membership in the study base is crucial in the discussion of nested case control, case cohort, and case base designs.
Therefore, an appreciation of potential sources of bias has becomea critical issue in epidemiology. In general, survivorship bias plays a huge role in medicine whether it be in studies or in an actual clinic. Consideration of the time of membership in the study base is crucial in the discussion of nested casecontrol, casecohort, and casebase designs. Selection bias in caseecontrol studies occurs when control selection is inappropriate. Stratify on survival time and use a negative control article in journal of clinical epidemiology 672 august 20 with 111 reads. My first example is about casecontrol studies of pancreatic cancer, which is when people with pancreatic cancer are compared to similar people without it in order to determine risk factors. Selection biasspecifically, survivor biasis a serious threat in casecontrol studies, and it can occur when the exposure or a cause of the exposure and the outcome or a cause of the outcome are conditionally associated within survival time. Selection bias as viewed as a problem with samples duration. Potential for bias and confounding from sampling two populations does not establish sequence of events potential survivor bias limited to one outcome variable does not yield prevalence, incidence or excess risk nested casecontrol advantages of retrospective cohort study but more efficient may require banked samples or data stored until. These studies generally showed a timedependent decline in infection risk in patients treated with antitnf agents, but this apparent drop off in risk over time is largely due to survivor bias. For example, in a cohort study investigating effects of jogging on.
What are some good real world examples of survivorship bias. We discuss two classes of bias that arise in case control studies, selection bias and information bias. The bias can be negativeresulting in underestimation of the exposure effector positive, and can even reverse the apparent direction of effect. The aim of this paper is to address these issues for retrospective casecontrol studies. Lijferinga,b,c adepartment of thrombosis and hemostasis, leiden university medical center, leiden, the netherlands beinthoven laboratory for experimental vascular medicine, leiden university. Confounding and bias in casecontrol studies, chinglan cheng.
Survivorship bias also presents a problem in the medical aspect like in clinical studies. Case series may be consecutive or nonconsecutive, depending on whether all cases presenting to the reporting authors over a period were included, or. Nov 15, 2014 many cohort studies make use of existing routine, surveillance systems to ascertain the outcomes of interest. A population based casecontrol study was performed. Selection bias and its implications for casecontrol. All babies with cleft lip referred for corrective surgery in norway between 1996 and 2001 were identified. Survivorship bias or survivor bias is a statistical artifact in applications outside finance, where studies on the remaining population are fallaciously compared with the historic average despite the survivors having unusual properties. When present, it results in a biased estimate of the effect of exposure on disease. Casecontrol studies e r i c n o t e b o o k s e r i e s casecontrol studies are used to determine if there is an association between an exposure and a specific health outcome. Identifying potential biases in the nephrology literature. Adjusting for selection bias in retrospective, casecontrol. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the impact of survivor bias on pancreatic cancer casecontrol. Diagnoses case selection may be influenced by physicians knowledge of exposure example. Disadvantages of cohort studies cohort studies have important limitations too.
Cases are those who experience the event of interest, and controls are a random sample from the source population from which the cases arose. The effect of survival bias on casecontrol genetic association. Often, survivorship bias can be extremely hard to discover. However, it actually only applies to those case control studies in which controls are sampled only from the nondiseased rather than the whole population. Researchers explored the association between maternal intake of folic acid supplements, multivitamins, and dietary folates in the prevention of cleft lip with or without cleft palate in the mothers babies. Bias, confounding and causality flashcards quizlet. Selection bias and its implications for casecontrol studies. Introduction to observational studies neuroophthalmology. Case losses in pancreatic cancer casecontrol studies could therefore introduce survivor bias. Uncovering selection bias in casecontrol studies using. Jul 24, 2018 understanding survivorship bias and how it can cloud your judgment is the key to becoming a sharper, more critical thinking. Remember that selection bias may occur in a cohort study if the rate of participa tion or the rate of loss to followup differ by both exposure and health outcome. Mezei and kheifets 2006 show that selection bias in casecontrol studies can lead to overestimating the true odds ratio by up to a factor of 2.
Survivor bias is another often overlooked bias in many cohort and case control studies. Alarge number of different sources and possible mechanisms of. As such, casecontrol studies are often used to generate or test hypotheses about causal factors. At a minimum, initiation of therapy should be treated as a timedependent covariate in a proportional hazards model.
Selection bias specifically, survivor bias is a serious threat in casecontrol studies and it can occur when the exposure or a cause of the exposure and the outcome or a cause of the outcome are conditionally associated within survival time 11. Radiologist aware of patients smoking status when reading. The authors constructed five case loss scenarios based on the. Survivor bias is another often overlooked bias in many cohort and casecontrol studies.
By contrast, case control studies cannot provide incidence rates. Confounding and bias in casecontrol studies chinglan cheng, ph. If they are recognized beforehand, it is possible to minimize or avoid them. Survivor bias financial definition of survivor bias. Sources of bias in casecontrol studies recall bias occurs when the recall is better among cases than controls because of the presence of the disease. Prevalence of survivor bias in observational studies on fresh. For rare diseases, such as cancers, casecontrol design is now the accepted and most common approach. Our simulation shows that the impact of survival bias is relatively small for most cohort ages and variant lethalities, and is further minimized by proactive enrollment of lethal cases.
It is a concern no matter what the design of the study or what statistic is used to. Case control studies are particularly suitable for the study of relatively rare diseases with long induction period, such as cancer. Confounding should always be addressed in studies concerned with causality. That can lead to better teamdecision making, building a more cohesive product, or making datadriven decisions like a scientist. Case control study outcome is pulmonary disease, exposure is smoking. Selection bias examples also occurs before subjects are identified for study diagnostic or workup bias. Design, conduct, and analysis of case control studies.
In casecontrol studies, survivor bias can occur when cases are selected a long period following the event being studied, with exposed cases having an increased risk of severe illness or death compared with nonexposed cases during the selection period. Case losses in pancreatic cancer casecontrol studies could therefore introduce survivor. Casecontrol studies are often used to identify factors that may contribute to a medical condition by comparing subjects who have that conditiondisease the cases with. They can be as credible as randomized studies, when correctly designed and performed. The effect of survival bias on casecontrol genetic. For example, a recent genomewide association study of ischemic stroke, based on a metaanalysis of longitudinal cohort data, demonstrated an. Unfortunately, misanalysis of survivor treatment selection bias has been prevalent in the recent literature on the acquired immunodeficiency syndrome.
Selection bias arises either when cases in the study sample are not representative of cases arising from the source population study base or when controls are not representative of corresponding noncases in the study base. Role of survivor bias in pancreatic cancer case control studies. Selection bias unc gillings school of global public health. One of the most significant triumphs of the casecontrol study was the demonstration of the link between tobacco smoking and lung cancer, by richard doll and bradford hill. Casecontrol studies are therefore placed low in the hierarchy of evidence. To learn when it is ideal to use a case control study design 2. A case series also known as a clinical series is a type of medical research study that tracks subjects with a known exposure, such as patients who have received a similar treatment, or examines their medical records for exposure and outcome. Selection bias in epidemiological studies teachepi. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the impact of survivor bias on pancreatic cancer casecontrol studies. Rr of exsmokers is lower than current smokers, higher than nonsmokers.
798 982 1019 500 757 53 683 529 134 1562 1440 363 1564 1469 1230 514 1040 1384 534 252 380 1415 554 803 562 49 22 748 606 1220 968 918